04 Ideation
Weighing three approaches to menu discovery.
I narrowed the menu search problem to three possible approaches,
drawing from features on everyday platforms that unconsciously
made recall easier and integrated smoothly into the flow: an
autofill suggestion bar, a searchable menu, and an @ symbol
shortcut to trigger search.
| Approach |
✓ Strengths |
✗ Weaknesses |
Autofill / Suggestion Bar |
- Helps find menu items given a small keyword
- Seamlessly adds items into the notes field
- Familiar from iMessage and other apps
|
- Multiple items may start with the same word
- Won't help if user can't remember any keywords
- May autofill words unrelated to the menu item
|
| Menu Search |
- Browse the full menu without remembering names
- Keyword search also available
- Categories make items easy to find
|
- More taps: search → scroll → click on item
- Must repeat the process for each item added
|
@ Symbol to Trigger Search |
- Signals intent to autofill a menu item
- Familiar from @-mentioning on other platforms
|
-
May confuse users who want to type the symbol literally
- Users may not discover it activates search
|
I decided to combine autofill and menu search.
If users remember part of a dish, autofill helps them find it
instantly. If they don't remember anything, they can browse the full
menu by category. Together, these features make finding dishes easy
without introducing a new interaction pattern.